The short answer: two citrus flavors or six flavors to sample
The Grapefruit Lemon Combo and the Fruit Flavored Variety Pack are the same size and the same catalog price: 24 cartons for USD 35.25. The decision comes down to flavor focus. The combo gives you tart grapefruit and fresh lemon across all 24 cartons. The variety pack splits the case into six natural fruit flavors, four cartons each.
If you already know you like citrus, the combo is the straightforward pick. If you want to try several flavors before committing to a full case of one, the variety pack does that job. Neither pack is inherently better; they answer different questions.
What each pack actually contains
- Grapefruit Lemon Combo: The Grapefruit Lemon Combo is a 24-pack of Grapefruit and Lemon fruit flavored water, both sugar free with natural flavors in 100% purified water. Every carton is one of the two citrus flavors, so the whole case is built around a flavor pairing you either like or don't.

Grapefruit Lemon Combo - Fruit Flavored Variety Pack: The Fruit Flavored Variety Pack is a 24-pack with four cartons each of Lemon, Watermelon, Blackberry, Cucumber, Mango, and Grapefruit. The fixed four-per-flavor split is the key difference: you get breadth, but only four cartons of any single flavor.

Fruit Flavored Variety Pack
Side-by-side on the points that affect the purchase
- Flavor range: Combo: two citrus flavors. Variety Pack: six flavors, including two citrus options (Lemon and Grapefruit).
- Cartons per flavor: Combo: the case is split between Grapefruit and Lemon, so you get a larger share of each. Variety Pack: exactly four cartons of each of the six flavors.
- Sugar and sweetener profile: The combo is described as sugar free with natural flavors. The variety pack is described as zero calories with zero artificial sweeteners. Both descriptions come from the supplied catalog information; check the carton label for the full ingredient list.
- Packaging: The combo is described as using the classic 92% plant-based carton. The supplied variety pack information does not specify carton material, so treat that as unconfirmed rather than different.
- Price and pack size: Both are listed at USD 35.25 for a 24-pack, with the same catalog comparison price of USD 55.95.
When the Grapefruit Lemon Combo is the better buy
Choose the combo if citrus is your default. Tart grapefruit and fresh lemon are the two flavors here, and buying the combo means you are not spending cartons on watermelon, blackberry, cucumber, or mango that you might not want. It also suits households where more than one person reaches for citrus, since the whole case stays in a familiar flavor lane.
The tradeoff is obvious: no variety. If you get bored with two flavors, the combo offers no escape hatch. That is not a flaw, just the nature of a focused pack.
When the Fruit Flavored Variety Pack is the better buy
Choose the variety pack if you are still figuring out which flavors you like, or if you want a mixed flavor boxed water pack for a shared fridge, an office, or a household with different preferences. The four-carton split means everyone can find something, and you can taste cucumber or blackberry without committing to a full case.
The tradeoff is that four cartons of any one flavor go quickly. If you discover a favorite, you will finish it long before the rest of the case. The variety pack is a sampler, not a stock-up.
A quick way to decide
- You already know you like citrus: Take the Grapefruit Lemon Combo and skip the guesswork.
- You have never tried these flavors: Start with the Fruit Flavored Variety Pack to find your favorite before buying a full case.
- You are buying for a group: The variety pack covers more tastes; the combo works if the group already leans citrus.
- You want the most cartons of one flavor: The combo gives you more Grapefruit and Lemon per case than the variety pack's four-carton allotment.
What the supplied information does not tell you
Neither product record includes preparation instructions, storage temperatures, or a stated shelf life. The records also do not list allergen information or a full ingredient breakdown beyond the flavor and sweetener descriptions above. If any of those details matter for your household, check the carton label or contact the store before ordering. The absence of those details in this comparison is a limit of the supplied catalog information, not a suggestion that the products lack them.


